Americas view | Brazil's football stadiums

Grumbling in the terraces

Customer service still leaves something to be desired

By A.D. | SÃO PAULO

GETTING schools and hospitals built to the same standard as World Cup stadiums was one of the main demands made by protesters on the streets of Brazil last month. But just days after FIFA, football’s governing body, handed the national stadium in Brasilia back to its owners following the Confederations Cup, a warm-up tournament ahead of next year’s World Cup, it appears that the problem is not just overspending and late delivery. It’s also management.

The 52,825 people who watched Flamengo play Coritiba on July 6th were treated rather differently to the elites who paid top prices to attend the inaugural Confederations Cup match three weeks earlier. Gone were the neat concession stands, the hundreds of volunteers and the top-class facilities for media. Instead, fans and press had the kind of experience that is depressingly familiar at Brazil’s football grounds.

The internet didn’t work, the radio reporters were forced to narrate the game from the stands, and fans were tossed drinks from a big fridge rather than served from behind counters. Even getting to the stadium was difficult: whereas busy avenues were closed to traffic during the Confederations Cup to improve access to the venue, fans now have to run a gauntlet of cars in order to reach the turnstiles. The promised tramlines have yet to materialise.

Complaints are not aimed at FIFA, which during the Confederations Cup provided a level of service to match the ticket prices. Rather, it is aimed at the Brazilian stadium managers who seem to be incapable of providing the same treatment. “The problem is that FIFA’s organisation is extremely professional,” says Ricardo Araujo, a stadium management consultant and author of Novas Arenas, a stadium blog. “They are experienced and have run events the world over for a long time while the people that are taking over the arenas in Brazil have very few competent people on board.”

The amateurishness left a bitter taste in the mouths of fans who had hoped the new stadiums, most of which were built with public funding, would also mark a new era in value for money. Ticket prices in Brazil have quadrupled over the past ten years, and the average attendance at top level games is now less than 13,000, according to Pluri, a sports consultancy. Today, more people go to see first-division games in China (which has qualified for the World Cup only once) than in football-mad Brazil.

Brazilian clubs and their fans are hoping the construction of 14 new stadiums in time for the World Cup next year will lure supporters who have been scared off by high prices, insecurity and inconvenient kick-off times back into the grounds. The experience in Brasilia last weekend does not bode well. Brazilian clubs, and the people running their stadiums, need to up their game.

More from Americas view

Business backlash

A weakened Enrique Peña Nieto faces calls to roll back his tax reform

Back to the table

The FARC's kidnapping of a Colombian general last month did not kill the peace process


The new brooms

Dilma Rousseff's new economic team talk about their plans