The CPD Blog is intended to stimulate dialog among scholars and practitioners from around the world in the public diplomacy sphere. The opinions represented here are the authors' own and do not necessarily reflect CPD's views. For blogger guidelines, click here.
When the Internet Goes Dark, Who Gets to Tell the Story of War?
A few years ago, when I worked in communications at UNESCO’s office in Mexico, part of our work involved sharing poetry written in Indigenous languages through translations and digital content. I think of that work as cultural diplomacy in practice. An author could reach readers who would otherwise have missed the poem, and those readers could encounter a voice from Mexico on the author’s own terms. UNESCO’s participation in Mexico’s National Indigenous Languages Fair, whose 2021 edition focused on community-led language planning, illustrates the broader effort in Mexico. The fair’s program included a poetry reading, a discussion on language teaching and a presentation of an app for learning Mexican languages.
I thought about those translations when I read about UNESCO’s forthcoming report, Digital Governance in Times of Crisis. A poem needs a means to travel, and so does a reporter’s account of an attack. If a network goes down during a war, journalists may lose contact with sources just as people outside the country are trying to establish what happened. For public diplomacy, the question raised by UNESCO’s report is increasingly urgent. How can governments and international organizations engage with people overseas when the channels civilians and independent reporters rely on can themselves become targets?
In its 2023 Guidelines for the Governance of Digital Platforms, UNESCO set out a framework for protecting freedom of expression and access to information online. This year’s crisis work asks what happens to those protections under pressure. At the World Summit on the Information Society Forum in Geneva on July 7, UNESCO shared preliminary findings from research developed with Ingrid Volkmer of the University of Melbourne. The study drew on responses from more than 200 regulatory experts worldwide. Sixty-one percent said their national digital rules lacked crisis-specific provisions or were unsure whether such provisions existed. Respondents also identified gaps around cloud and satellite services. A national regulator may be responsible for keeping the public informed while having limited reach over the services its public relies on.
At a Nov. 9 roundtable alongside the Paris Peace Forum, UNESCO, Luxembourg’s permanent delegation and Access Now brought researchers and humanitarian practitioners into that discussion. UNESCO’s account describes a mismatch between systems that operate across borders and crisis arrangements that are still largely national. The discussion put the protection of data and the infrastructure that carries it on the same agenda. UNESCO plans to present the report formally at the Nov. 19–20 meeting of its Intergovernmental Council for the International Programme for the Development of Communication. The progression from Geneva to Paris turns a survey finding into a question governments and their partners can act on. Who can restore a service, who can see the data and whom should a local newsroom call?
"If mobile service failed tonight, who could still send a verified message, in which languages, and how would we hear back?"
Public diplomacy has long involved cultural programs, international broadcasting, exchanges and listening. Nicholas Cull’s history of the field also describes diplomats as people who build networks and relationships. Digital media made it easier for foreign publics to take part directly. A journalist could share a dispatch across borders, and a diaspora organization could challenge a government’s account in public. The same change made diplomatic engagement dependent on infrastructure that diplomats rarely control. In my doctoral research on war coverage, I ask whose account appears first and whom reporters cite. A newsroom that loses its connection may be unable to file while officials with working networks can still shape the first reports.
Hybrid warfare helps explain why that vulnerability matters today. James Mattis and Frank Hoffman used the term in U.S. defense debates in 2005. Hoffman developed it further in 2007, describing how an adversary can combine conventional force, irregular tactics and other forms of coercion in a single campaign. NATO’s current approach to hybrid threats also addresses cyberattacks and disinformation. An actor can use force to control conditions on the ground and interfere with the channels through which others report what happened. For public diplomats, this makes it harder to test an official account against independent reporting before communicating with foreign publics.
Myanmar illustrates the problem. On Nov. 15, ASEAN leaders condemned attacks on civilians in Myanmar and called for humanitarian access and inclusive dialogue. Access Now and the #KeepItOn coalition had already documented at least 95 deliberate internet shutdowns in Myanmar in 2025, out of at least 313 across 52 countries. In late January 2025, local military forces cut internet and phone service in Tamu Township as the military carried out airstrikes in nearby towns. People had fewer ways to warn one another, and local reporters had fewer ways to verify what was happening. The outage shows how a deliberate restriction can accompany military action. Elsewhere, an infrastructure failure can also leave civilians isolated, as U.N. humanitarian officials documented in Gaza in June 2025. The cause and the coordination behind any outage have to be established case by case.
For embassies and multilateral agencies, the practical question is how to keep listening when this happens. Independent Myanmar outlet Mizzima and Reporters Without Borders began a shortwave broadcast carrying news and practical information in August. A receiver can pick up the signal without an internet connection. That helps listeners stay informed. Diplomats also need safe channels in the other direction, so reporters and humanitarian organizations can tell them what people are experiencing. They can agree on backup contacts in advance, support independent outlets’ ability to keep operating and seek consent before publicly sharing accounts that could identify a source.
The pressure to answer quickly is especially strong when images of an attack circulate internationally. An embassy may want to correct a claim before it hardens into the accepted account. It can describe what it has verified, explain where its information comes from and say when it expects to know more. Giving a local newsroom time to verify its own reporting is part of that work. Public diplomats build credibility over time when the people they listen to can see how their accounts were used.
There is also a limit to what an institution should collect in the name of coordination. People searching for a relative, requesting evacuation or sending evidence of an attack may leave behind names and locations. Agencies can ask who needs that information, when it should be deleted and whether the same service can be provided with less of it. They can also publish corrections with timestamps and make clear when they are repeating a party’s claim. Those decisions affect whether local reporters and residents will trust official channels enough to use them again.
My work in Mexico started with a practical question about how a poem could reach another reader while keeping the author’s language present. During war, that question acquires a different urgency. Can a reporter get an account out safely? Can the people described in it speak for themselves? The UNESCO meeting gives public diplomacy teams a reason to test their own plans with local partners. If mobile service failed tonight, who could still send a verified message, in which languages, and how would we hear back?
Visit CPD's Online Library
Explore CPD's vast online database featuring the latest books, articles, speeches and information on international organizations dedicated to public diplomacy.
POPULAR ARTICLES
-
September 22
-
October 13
-
October 26
-
October 5
-
October 5
Join the Conversation
Interested in contributing to the CPD Blog? We welcome your posts. Read our guidelines and find out how you can submit blogs and photo essays >.









